Latest book reviews›› The Opposite of Everything by David KalishPower’s Out: Book Two: Troubled Times Series by Rachel Meehan13:24 A Story of Faith and Obsession by M Dolon HickmonBasement, a collection of short stories and poems by David PodlipnyThe Boy That Never Was by Karen PerryHow the Kudu got his Spiral Horns by HL FourieMurdered by James SchannepEntry Island by Peter MayBestiary for Business by Erica SchelbyGod’s Spy by Juan Gómez-JuradoThe Hobbit: Illustrated Edition by J.R.R. Tolkien (Author) , Jemima Catlin (Illustrator)Katie Did Learn the Five Senses B. Kirbo (Author), Dereck Van Wickel (Illustrator)The Invisible Hand by David GreenDimly, Through Glass by Dirk KnightThe In Between by Jeff GoinsTrash by Andy MulliganOn Chesil Beach by Ian McEwanA Patchwork Planet by Anne TylerWisdomkeepers by Steve Wall and Harvey ArdenAsh: Return of the Beast by Gary Val TenutaNot Without You by Harriet EvansSeaBEAN by Sarah HoldingMono No Aware by Angel ArandaDon’t Let Me Die In A 400 Square-Foot Studio by Amy WolfWater’s Edge (Troubled Times) by Rachel MeehanEarly One Morning by Robert RyanThe Eagle of the Ninth by Rosemary SutcliffEscaping the hell of Acid reflux by Chris LoukarosHow to be Selfish by Olga LevancukaDodged by Jason HummMidnight in Havana by Peggy BlairThe Singing Tree by Peter MossAlfie’s Guardian Angel by Vania Von VanistanOstrich by Matt GreeneDark Orchid by Michael J. ShanksMushy Maggie by Inola Clemmons WrightThe Missionary Position by Christopher HitchensPitt Doesn’t Eat by Ortal BerelmanThe Fall of the Angel Nathalie by Jamie BrindleThe Jade Pendant by L.P. LeungA Skeptics Luck by A D MorelBeem Explores Africa by Simidele DosekunA Place in the World by Cinda Crabbe MackinnonNew Stars for Old (Stories from the History of Astronomy) by Marc ReadEasy Prey (A Nathan Hawk Mystery) by Douglas WatkinsonChildren of the Jacaranda Tree by Sahar DelijaniNative Gold by Glynnis CampbellA Time of Myths by Chris BlamiresSeating Arrangements by Maggie ShipsteadTito Johnson’s Diary by W.B. EmersonVanguard of Hope by Kathy SteinemannAfter Flodden by Rosemary GoringOrphans Gold by David LoeffThe Teachers Pet by L.K. HunsakerDivorce Blues Recovery by Don LoveGranpa Guff the Accidental Astronaut by G. GuffWoman of Substance by Annette BowerChasing Dolphins by September Lynn GrayThe Psychic by Margaret FelicesSiberian Hellhole by Michael MulvihillLooking Back with a Smile by Edward FarberHiring Geeks that Fit by Johanna RothmanMoving On, a Prairie Romance by Annette BowerThe Book o’Samson (Cash Chronicles Book 1) by James L. MonticoneMogadishu Diaries: Insider Threat by Eddie ThompkinsRewire Your Brain for Love: Creating Vibrant Relationships Using the Science of Mindfulness by Marsha LucasHamilton Troll meets Pink Light Sprite by Kathleen J. SheildsDead Reckoning by K.A. PerkinsWriter’s Block Trilogy: The Possession by A.K. KuykendallTwelve Lessons by Kate SpencerUniversal Soul Reflections by Peter MutandaHow the Cockroach, after having died, Entered the Gates of Heaven by V. CampudoniThe Animal Bunch, Learn Colors by Aleli SilviaThe Inner road to Wisdom and Healing by Carol DeansPig Island by Mo HayderWake up and hear the Thunder by Eileen CampbellThe Blind Man’s Garden by Nadeem AslamJumping off the Page by Marty WeilDestination: Teach For America by Jake WhitmanEli Arnold and the Keys to Forever by John CarterDon’t Let Me Die in a Motel 6 by Amy WolfA Cold day for Murder by Dana StabenowAnother Unknown Soldier by A.M. SmithNeed to Breathe by Tara StaleyThe Dark Winter by David MarkThe Persecution of Mildred Dunlap by Paulette MahurinThe Scribe Remembered by Dr. K SaradamoniOnly the Dead will Know Peace by Jim MainA Restless Evil by Ann GrangerLife with Cancer by frank Terrazzano and Paul LonardoConnections to the Journey of Mankind by Edward L.WalshFlying to the Light by Elyse SalpeterReckless Rudy and the Green Vase by R.M. SmithStrangely Sober by Essa AlrocWhat we did on our Holiday by John HardingWake Up by Benjamin CardRoyal Flush by Scott BartlettDown at the Golden Coin by Kim StricklandWhistling for the Elephants by Sandi ToksvigInfected by James SchannepQuantum Healing by Deepack ChopraThe Mogadishu Diaries by Eddie ThompkinsThe Middle Passage by Julia GoldingA Very Bad Bad thing by John C. YiannoudisThe Dying Embers of an Alter Place by Marshall ParrentA Singular Hostage by Thalassa AliWhite Teeth by Zadie SmithJayden’s Revenge by Dirk KnightBridget Rowan’s Reality by Bridget RowanThat Day in September by Artie Van WhyHostile Witness by Rebecca Foster52 Pickup by Elmore LeonardHuman Croquet by Kate AtkinsonMarvin Piersoll by Bernard MendilloThe Rainbow Stick boy by Michael SantoliniScotland Zen and the Art of Social Work by J.A.SkinnerRoom by Emma DonoghueThe King of Pain by Seth KaufmanLife on the Other Side by Sylvia BrownePsychonavigation by John PerkinsFull Circle by Michael ‘Hawk’ SpisakThe Unbelievable truth by Gordon SmithThe Audacity of Hope by Barak ObamaNotes on a Scandal by Zoë HellerThe Earth Hums in B Flat by Mari StrachanThe Clothes on Their Backs by Linda GrantAlice Bliss by Laura HarringtonThe Colour of Law by Mark GiminezThe Sex Life of my Aunt by Mavis CheekThe Keeper of the Bride by Tess GerritsenCane River by Lalita TademyIshmael by Daniel QuinnA Price for Everything by Mary SheepshanksThe Bookseller of Kabul by Asne SeierstadRandom Acts of Heroic Love By Danny ScheinmannA Lesser Dependancy by Peter BensonWe Know by Gregg HurwitzSeventy Two Virgins by Boris JohnsonBlue Monday by Nicci FrenchThe Horse at the Gates by D.C.AldenViolet Jelly by Ann SharplesThe Rain Before it Falls by Jonathan CoeOne Door Away from Heaven by Dean KoontzToast by Nigel SlaterDark Paradise by Tami HoagPassing Places by Amanda MacandrewThe Underside of Joy by Sere Prince HalversonA Necessary End by Peter RobinsonYou Got Nothing Coming by Jimmy LernerThe Brutal Art by Jesse KellermanLove in the Present Tense by Cathrine Ryan HydeOne Good Turn by Kate AtkinsonDancing In a Distant Place by Isla DewarThe Best a Man Can Get – by John O’FarrellThe Choice by Bernadette BohanThe Slap by Christos TsiolkasHalf of a Yellow Sun by Chimamanda Ngozi AdichieThe Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time by Mark HaddonThe Tent by Michael Boxall
The Mogadishu Diaries by Eddie Thompkins
Follow Published may 2012
Fiction based on fact.

The Mogadishu Diaries by Eddie Thompkins

Site Score
5.7
Good: Realistic Writing
Bad: No glossary for unfamiliar terms
User Score
9.0
(1 votes)
Click to vote
VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 9.0/10 (1 vote cast)

Book Description (from author)

Ten months before Blackhawk Down, US Marines launched its first major offensive against Mogadishu’s militias. Top US military strategists for Operation Restore Hope recognized the critical importance of identifying Somali clan leaders responsible for the country’s instability and violence. It became apparent that one man needed to be captured in order to help establish order. This warlord eluded the most elite US Special Forces teams in our military for almost a year during Operation Restore Hope/Continued Hope. There are many theories that explain how Mohamed Farrah Aidid won the cat and mouse game. This is my account…
Stills from the VHS tape capturing the US Marine Air/Ground assault are featured in this book.
Front cover image courtesy of Roland Ocampo
Echo Co. 2/9 Weapons platoon USMC

Book Review

This is fiction based on real events, but it is more than a just another journal type story. It really makes you feel you knew what went on, on the ground, and in the heads of the military men (and women) in the story. I would have liked a glossary for the unfamiliar terms but got by with a dictionary and a bit of imagination.
The internal politics and rivalries in the military ranks were well told and the story moved at a fast pace. There was an accurate history of Somalia included, from 1969 to 1991 which helped put some background to the events of 1992.
I found it interesting that the rules could be bent in certain situations like the time when some women were being attacked and raped by gang members and there were no regrets or comebacks, and when a patrol of ‘Project feed Somalia’ was not disarmed as they were on a mission of mercy. This ended badly but not through any fault of the patrol involved.
Gunnery Thomson is a likable character who values his friendships and does everything he can to help his mate Ramirez in his career advancement. He spends time with the interpreters and shows them respect and also has his eye on one attractive female Somali interpreter.
The writer is able, very concisely, to paint word pictures to describe his colleagues and superiors with wit and humour, which gives the story reality. I hope there is another book in the pipeline as I would like to know if Thompson ever gets together with the girl, and would like to know about his family. For me, he has done what good writers do, he leaves you wanting more.

Guest Reviewer    Marshal Parrent

I read Eddie Clay’s book as two different readers: The U.S. Army veteran and the college English professor. The veteran in me liked the book, and because I could relate to the protagonist. As a solider, I experienced first-hand some of the very same issues as our Gunnery Sergeant Thompson: following orders that simply weren’t logical, working under egotistical and childish officers hell bent on making your life a living hell, and overeager NCOs willing to topple anyone that stood in the way of their promotion (or the CO’s butt). The book brought me back to the days I served from 1997-2001. It revived the memories of those men and women I served with that had in fact seen action in Somalia, their stories faded like old newspaper pages until now. It reminded me of every little frustrating or invigorating nuance that was standard issue with military life. Those were good days then, and my enlistment immeasurably shaped my life for the better. I’m grateful for having read this book and been reminded of all of that.

However, the English teacher in me had a few issues with this novel. I enjoyed the nostalgia, the story overall and the first-hand perspective from an enlisted man, but I couldn’t get passed some of the problems with the writing. First off, a reader unfamiliar withU.S.military jargon may find the book difficult to follow. I’ve found that when you write about the military, it’s best to treat it like science fiction or fantasy: The places, the nomenclature and the special circumstances of the characters must be explained in an entertaining and thoughtful way for an audience that does not know or understand this new world.  I would certainly recommend that the writer keep in mind that only a small portion of his audience will understand how the American military works, and to write for everyone in mind.

Despite some issues with punctuation, the novel was readable. I can certainly live with the unnecessary and at times incorrect use of ellipses. What I really had trouble with, though, was the organization of the book. Each chapter is quite short, and at times painfully so. Chapter 11, for example, explains the general situation inSomalia, and in just one page. The action comes to an abrupt halt in this chapter to explain to the reader what’s going on. This information would have been better served to the reader if it were integrated into the story. A footnote would have sufficed. Each chapter should advance the story in some form or fashion. On occasion, a chapter would end in the middle of a scene and then resume in the next chapter, which honestly didn’t make much sense.

Parts of the narrative were either confusing or went nowhere. For example, the protagonist, Gunnery Sergeant Thompson, falls for a female interpreter. He goes through some great pains to woo her and learn more about this native Somalian’s culture. After some effort, it appeared as though she was warming up the Gunny, but then we never hear about this budding relationship again. It seemed to be an important part of this fictionalized account, but the author seemed to forget about this part. Also, the ending of the book, and how the arrogant and menacing Captain Shaffner was finally outsmarted, was quite frankly confusing.

Overall, I don’t think Clay’s book is bad; however, it could use some improvements. I enjoyed reading it and because I am familiar with the military and enjoy war stories. If you want to read a fresh perspective of America’s involvement in Somalia(that has absolutely nothing to do with Black Hawk Down), take the time to read this novella.

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 9.0/10 (1 vote cast)
The Mogadishu Diaries by Eddie Thompkins, 9.0 out of 10 based on 1 rating

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Rate This Item

CommentLuv badge